Monday, July 9, 2012

The Taliban Executes Woman to Shouts of "Allahu Akbar"

Westerners need to make up their minds. On the one hand, people keep saying that it's wrong to judge other cultures, that all beliefs are equal, "to each his own," and so on. On the other hand, we condemn the Taliban for executing a woman. But if it's wrong for the Taliban to execute a woman on trumped up charges, then all cultures are not created equal. And if cultures aren't necessarily equal, then we can engage in the process of judging cultures. I vote against the culture displayed in this video:

14 comments:

kiwimac said...

This sickens me to the stomach. There is nothing in this atrocity that should involve even the mention of God or 'a God'. This is murder- A young Girl,innocent in life is killed while the killers try to make it out to be a 'Holy'or 'Moral' act! Disgusting!

AD said...

Believe it or not this actually gives me hope - because the majority of the people there were against it, were shocked by it and condemned it. The fact tht it was 'noticed' & taken cognizance of from the highest levels of the govt there is also good news.

SGM said...

After watching the video, I was wondering why they are blaming the Talaban. The question is, Who are the Talaban? They are the devout moslems who were shouting Allah hu akbar while the women was being shot. I come from a moslem country and let me tell you, every moslem is a Talaban. Talaban is a word that moslems and some westerners are using to blame all the problems to in the moslem world. This is a diversion to make Islam look good. Whereas, these Talaban are the same people that make up the societies in every country. Now it is also true that there are some moslems who don't like the type of voilence shown in this video but then these are the people who don't know the Quranic teachings about women.

Think about this. According to 2012 Human Rights report, 9 out 10 women in Afghanistan suffer violence of some shape or form. If Talaban are such a minority, then this ratio should be lot less. However, 9 out 10 ten women suffering violence shows that majority of the country then is Talaban.

This is Islam for you.

Richard said...

"Muslim Cleric Wants to Destroy Christianity"

Sheik Farook al-Mohammedi and his group United Muslim Nations International has released their plan in a 23 page booklet to rid the world of Christianity, “wipe Christianity from the face of the earth,” Islamize the West and establish an Islamic system of world government – placing those who resist “under a police state.”

“Islamic Power has returned upon the face of the earth and the Revived Global Caliphate has set eyes on the West to once and for all rid the world of Christianity, and there is nothing you can do about it,” al-Mohammedi said, “I have pledged and made a firm promise to the Caliphate of the United Muslim Nations International organization that I will do my utmost to Islamize all of the West within a short period of time.”

http://guardianlv.com/2012/07/muslim-cleric-wants-to-destroy-christianity/

reconnaissance said...

"Sheik Farook al-Mohammedi and his group United Muslim Nations International has released their plan in a 23 page booklet to rid the world of Christianity, “wipe Christianity from the face of the earth,” Islamize the West and establish an Islamic system of world government – placing those who resist “under a police state.”


It's like a movie or cartoon where the bad guys are obsessed with conquering the world just to conquer it. How dumb.

kiwimac said...

David- What intrigues me personally in reference to Islam, is what drives people such as Anjem Choudary and Osama Abdallah to continue to defend Islam in the face of continued violence, atrocity,oppression and child marriage in the Muslim World? Do they truly believe that Islam is separate from these atrocities or do they actually support them - because the ultimate goal is world domination at any cost?

Osama Abdallah said...

The killing of innocent people is always wrong, especially when there are children. I don't know the whole story of why the Taliban did what they did. However, notice how YOUR WOMEN were laughing their asses off about the man who got his penis cut off by his wife because he wanted to file for divorce:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nrvDhSB7GHk&feature=related


No matter how you slice it, Islam is the Ultimate Truth and Justice! Your women and your men are eternal enemies! It's as clear as the sun. In Islam, there is peace and family-friendly society, because everyone has obligations and boundaries that he/she can't transgress depending on what his/her role in life is. In your cuntography societies you have nothing but confusion and hatered. I find the women who were joking and the ones who were cheering to be quite appauling. But then again, this is what you get from the ideology of toilets.

Osama Abdallah
www.answering-christianity.com

Osama Abdallah said...

And its funny how it's those same women who cry loud about women's rights in the world. Why should any man care about any of your women getting raped or abused when you treat men with total disregard and disrespect? Again, men and women in the west are Eternal Enemies! I don't see any peace and harmony in this.

Osama Abdallah
www.answering-christianity.com

Ashley said...

ah, you're absolutely right, osama. ladies joking about a man's penis getting bit off is way more serious than muslims blowing womens' heads off because of some perceived crime against their savage morality system. you are so right. where can i sign up for this englightened religion?

kiwimac said...

Osama- Maybe that innocent 22 yr old Woman might still be alive, if those Taleban commanders had had their penises sliced off?

John 8:24 said...

David,

I am not sure if you saw this opinion piece on CNN by Imam Feisal Abdul Rauf and Daisy Khan titled "Islam key to Afghan Dream" in response to this incident.

http://edition.cnn.com/2012/07/11/opinion/opinion-rauf-khan-islam-women/index.html

It is rather disappointing that CNN would promote such a twisted-beyond-belief opinion piece. It is one thing to say Islam is not responsible for this (ahem..???) but it is outright crazy to use this incident to say that Afghanis needs more of Islam!

I am not sure if you (or anyone else here) got time but it calls for a response - in video preferably ;-)

Osama Abdallah said...

"Osama- Maybe that innocent 22 yr old Woman might still be alive, if those Taleban commanders had had their penises sliced off?"

RESPONSE:

These cases are so rare in the Muslim world, that when someone gets caught and executed, it makes headlines here in the west. I agree with protecting the sacredness and sanctity of marriage. Violaters of it should meet their punishments.
Same goes for punishing criminals.

All you have to do is don't be whore and you'll get along wit the Law just fine.

Osama Abdallah
www.answering-christianity.com

Osama Abdallah said...

By the way, the cheering of the crowd wasn't for vengence against the woman. It was a celebration for her to going to Heaven, because her sin was punished in this world and not in the lifeafter.

May Allah Almighty rest her soul and enter her into Heaven. Ameen.

Osama Abdallah
www.answering-christianity.com

Osama Abdallah said...

"Osama- Maybe that innocent 22 yr old Woman might still be alive, if those Taleban commanders had had their penises sliced off?"

RESPONSE:

There is no proof that the woman committed adultery with any of the Taliban commanders. This was a speculation from CNN.
However, whomever she slept with, according to Islam, both the MAN AND WOMAN are to be punished. Not just the woman.

If the Taliban did this unjustly to coverup, then they bear the curse of GOD Almighty on their heads.

Osama Abdallah
www.answering-christianity.com