For those of you who don't like the superior technology of Motionbox, here's the Google Video version of my debate with Osama Abdallah.
OSAMA'S OPENING STATEMENT
DAVID'S OPENING STATEMENT
OSAMA'S FIRST REBUTTAL
DAVID'S FIRST REBUTTAL
SECOND REBUTTALS, Q&A, CONCLUSIONS
Here's the Hadith we disputed about on killing dogs:
Sahih al-Bukhari 3323--Narrated Abdullah bin Umar: Allah's Messenger ordered that the dogs should be killed.
Osama accused me of lying and claimed that the passage says "rabid dogs." I corrected him, but then he thanked me for admitting that I had lied! I have trouble understanding how logic works in the Muslim world.
DAVID: "Al-Bukhari 3323 says that dogs should be killed."
OSAMA: "David's lying! It says 'rabid dogs.'"
DAVID: "The Hadith doesn't say anything about rabid dogs; you're thinking of a different Hadith."
OSAMA: "Thank you for admitting that you lied!"