Thursday, July 16, 2015

A Muslim Asks for Sources on the Stupidity of Women in the Hadith

I just got this request for sources:
As salam uu alikum brother. May Allah shows you the right path. I would really love to know the article you wrote about Muhammad (s) opinion on women's. Where did you found the conversation of Mohammed , where is said women have lack of sense? And if you don't have any then please die and may Allah send you to the hell as soon as possible. Allah Hafiz brother
Here are three ahadith on the deficiency of a woman's mind. I hope our Muslim friend is using these passages to learn that Islam is false, and not to throw them in his wife's face (or his wives' faces)!

Sahih al-Bukhari 2658:

Sahih al-Bukhari 304:

Sahih Muslim 241:

For more on women in Islam, watch this short introduction:


TPaul said...

Hmmmm .... Hilarious! First he curses you with death and to hell and then ends with " Allah Hafiz " brother....
Anyway I wonder how your schooling him in Islam will affect him now that he knows what Mohammed thought of women.

Unknown said...

This post demonstrates a key difference between Muslims & Christians. If this were a Christian responding to a Muslim claim, it would have ended not with anything to the effect of "If the evidence doesn't exist then please go to hell as soon as possible" but rather "If the evidence doesn't exist then I pray the Lord Jesus will open your eyes & ears to the truth so that you may accept His gift of redemption."

You see the occasional bigoted Christian here & there, but you see this type of Muslim far more often. Muslims seem to be especially incapable of handling the ugly truth gracefully. They resort to these sorts of nasty comments because that's all they have, and they come from a culture that tells them not that when they resort to this sort of behavior they've lost their case and should believe in the opposing case (as the world of logic & debate does), but that this will enable them to make that which is false true if they try hard enough.

Kufar Forever said...

This comment is from an ex muslima called salma on yahoo uk
As an ex Muslim woman, I can identify with what we watched last night (Escape from IS) and the way women treated in the Islamic world and the ME in particular. One might ask, why the Muslim countries around ISIS can't form an army of volunteers to purge ISIS for tarnishing their religion? After all, getting killed fighting such 'blasphemers' (Murtaddeen) is martyrdom and paves the way to paradise! To answer this, we need to understand what the Qura'n and Hadith commands Muslims on how to treat women. Here's a minute fraction of what both 'holy?' books say;
Qura'n (4:11) - (Inheritance) "The male shall have the equal of the portion of two females"
Qura'n (2:282) - (Court testimony) "And call to witness, from among your men, two witnesses. And if two men be not found then a man and two women."
Qura'n (2:228) -(social order) "and the men are a degree above them [women]"
Qura'n (4:3) - (Wife-to-husband ratio) "Marry women of your choice, two or three or four, or whatever number of ammah (sex slaves) you can own"
The Hadith says;
Bukhari (6:301) - "[Muhammad] said, 'Is not the evidence of two women equal to the witness of one man?' They replied in the affirmative. He said, 'This is the deficiency in her intelligence.'"
Bukhari (1:6:30) “Majority of women are in hell because they are deficient in intelligence”
Abu Dawud (41:5251) “A good Muslimah (Muslim woman in Arabic) readily undergoes female circumcision as it is better for her and more desirable for her husband”
Abu Dawud (3:29:3911) “A mat in the house is better than a barren woman”
Abu Dawud (11:2142) “A man must not be asked as to why he beats his wife”
Tabari (1990:9:112-114) “Women are domestic animals, beat them."

So, what ISIS is doing is fulfilling the commands of the Qura'n and Hadith, and hence, other Muslims can not touch them on this issue. This is how they're getting away with it; their practices are wholly Islamic!
I certainly welcome modernisation of a religion that has been stuck in 7th century AD, and all for liberating the minds of its followers whom refuse to 'evolve' and join modern human race. But, until they remove such verses and texts, it will remain a catch 22 situation.

LadyTerri said...

Well alrighty then....that escalated rather quickly.. The guy was doing great up until the part were he said "please die and may Allah send you to hell as soon as possible". Yeah it kinda went all down hill from there.

One of the strangest things that I have noticed is the Muslims extreme denial of there own scriptures. They claim they know the Qur'an and the life of their prophet but yet turn around and deny he did anything the hadiths say he did. He robbed caravans he had slaves he married a child and consummated that marriage before she was of age, he married his adopted son's wife...there hadiths say it very clearly. But yet when you quote it to them they excuse it all away into this cloud of denial and then call us all liars...It's like they live in Bizarro World.

Unknown said...

"And if you don't have any then please die and may Allah send you to the hell as soon as possible"

Such a polite Muslim lol

Ali said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Unknown said...

The bible is greater than the quran

Unknown said...

listen all muslims are not terrorist and all terrorist are not muslims

jesus(pbuh) is not a god understand what bible says then you come to quran
if you peoples say that jesus(pbuh) is god he never said in the bible that he is a god
if you considered him to be a son of god because he has no father but born to virgin women(mary) then i will say adam(as) does not have a father and mother then he must be considered to be greater son of god

if you still believe that jesus(pbuh) is a son of god then you why are praying the son(ie.jesus(pbuh) come to the god(ie.allah)
basically the father is more powerfull than his son

and may allah(swt) puts light in your hearts and save us from hell fire

Unknown said...

Mr. Areola,please let me tell you, we Muslim we don't say Bible or qur-an is big what what.what we say all the books of Prophets are good and write.we don't believe one and deny another. the book of Jesus(Issa),the book of David(DAUD),THE BOOK OF MOSSES(MUSA) AND THE LAST BOOK OF PROPHET MUHAMMAD SAW ARE BOOKS FROM ALLAH SW TO HIS PROPHETS.

Unknown said...

Yyy... "we dont believe one and deny another". If I was given ten dollars every time a muslim told me "Bible was corrupted", Id be a very rich person today ^^ of course muslims believe one book (Quran) while denying another one (Bible). Which makes no sense if we take into consideration, that Bible was sent by Allah (according to Quran) n later on Christians n Jews corrupted it, despite the Quran states that Allahs word cant be changed. Christians n Jews did it, so they r more powerful than Allah, logically. The argument "Bible was corrupted" is so illogical that its beyond my understanding.

Unknown said...

Sorry Dr.wood but you need a more accurate translation of these hadiths you pested