Wednesday, May 22, 2013

Steven Crowder: Jesus vs. Muhammad (Qur'an Challenge II)

Steven Crowder has posted his latest "Qur'an Challenge":


Here's the original Qur'an Challenge.

24 comments:

cheryl_maree said...

I WAS NOT offended by seeing Jesus, now ask yourself this question. Why are you offended by seeing Muhammed, WHY?? I was NOT offended because I know MY JESUS and who he is. The muslims are offended because of their prophet and what he did and that is exactly why they get upset.

JP Pŕáşãď said...

@ Quran challenge
This guy makes such video, now those muslims start new riots n killing non muslims on basis of this type video,, may be who knows,,lol

BOOTA SINGH said...

Jesus never did any shameful acts,but what Mr Mo did, embracing for entire muslim umma(nation).

akairey said...

Great JOB Rowder! @ David..thanks for posting these!!!

David said...

This should be called NOT Jesus Vs NOT Mohammed. Jesus never looked like this and he certainly doesnt look like this today.

Christian Ortolf said...

I don't think Hadith is worth quoting for any kind of argument for or against Islam.

Quote Quran or don't quote at all.

Lia Hu said...

Muhammad (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him (PBUH)) is not a common person, so we should respect him accordingly. He (PBUH) is the Messenger of Allah (God). He brought us the last testimony of Allah (God) which is The Holy Quran. His (PBUH) life and the holy Quran together provide us the code of successful life. If we know the teachings of Jesus (PBUH), He (Jesus)confirms Muhammad's (PBUH) arrival and bound His (Jesus) followers to become faithful to Muhammad (PBUH), because Prophet Muhammad is the last Messenger of Allah (God).
Mother Ayesha's wedding with the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH)at young age is the special blessing of Allah (God) on the human race. She was chosen to get lifelong guidance from the Prophet and train/reveal it to the Humanity (especialy our sisters, mothers and wife (or wives)). However, if you really want to be enlightened. I will encourage you to read a book on the life of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). Why? because then you will know who is Muhammad (PBUH). It is everybody's duty to get knowledge (most important! true knowledge).

aaron said...

this is too funny at muslim tantrums not one showing anything useful.

@david

can you make a video on asiha's age then point out that even the jewish minimal age of marriage is better then muhummed's

Sancho Panza said...

Just a small correction: Charles Bronson is of Polish extraction.

Lia Hu said...

David, I encourage you to read my previous comment and try to get the point. Muhammad (PBUH) is the prophet of Allah (God), His life is not anybody's life. He was chosen to revoulationize the world. Whatever he brought and did is from the God. You can not comment on His life to make fun. Because it won't be fair on your part. Over billion people LOVE Him (PBUH), you atleast respect their LOVE for the Prophet.

BOOTA SINGH said...


@ Lia Hu
Jesus was not a sinner, so he does not need any mercy. Infact the Holy Bible, Qur’an and other Islamic sources claim that Jesus was without any sin. In sura Mariam 19:19 it clearly states that Jesus is the only one who Allah had said that he is the righteous son (Holy Son) without any sin. Sura Al-Imran 3:35-37 state that Mary and her offspring (Jesus) were protected from Satan. In other hadiths, narrated, said bin Al-Musaiyab: abu Huraira said, “I heard Allah’s Apostle saying “there is non-born among the off-spring of Adam, but Satan touches it. A child cries therefore, cries, loudly at the time of birth because of the touch of Satan, EXCEPT MARY AND HER CHILD.” (Sahih Al-Bukhari, Volume 4, No 641,506).On the other hand Muhammad was asked, to ask for the forgiveness of his sins. Qur’an surah 47:19: and ask forgiveness for your sin, and also for (the sin of) believing men and believing women. Al-Hilali & Khan. Check other surah’s from Qur’an 40:55.
Jesus never said that Muhammad is coming, in fact he confirms about the false prophets coming after him and Jesus said: you will come to know by their fruit. Read Jesus own words about the advent of false prophets like Muhammad. Matthew 24:11.
You call a 6 year old child marrying to Muhammad age 54, a blessing of Allah, shame on you, I call it child molesting and rape. In a modern world we call it paedophilia. What she was going to teach her other fellow girls, how to get rape, by a man who is double the age of her father. She was psychology, emotionally and physically abused by this man called Mr Mo (your special prophet) Book 004, Number 2127: Ayesha narrated. "He struck me on the chest which caused me pain." Remember that it was not softly as your modern day Muslim scholars are telling you. Ayesha your little mum is complaining that he stuck me so hard on the “chest which causes me pain”. Shame on you Muhammad who was hitting 8 years old girl. So it prove that your prophet not only sexually abusing the minors. On other had he was criminal by hitting your little mum, in a civilised societies we call it domestic violence.
At last I have read your recommended book, “Life of Muhammad”. In my opinion its not book of knowledge, It’s a complete trash, book of lies. I think you should change the name of this book, change it to “Life of Scumbag”. Enjoy have a nice day...
Seek for Love and Mercy of our Lord Jesus Christ...
Peace.

TPaul said...

Lia Hu,
You like the rest of your musalmah sisters are suffering from a condition called Stockholm syndrome, wherein the oppressed becomes thankful to the oppressor.
It is a fact stated in both the Koran and hadiths, that Mohammed and his puppet Allah both had absolutely no regard for women.

There are explicit commands for men to 'beat' women while they are told to that women are tilth.
Mohammed said most of the inhabitants of hell are women and that they are deficient in intelligence.

Are you? If you blindly praise Mohammed, without seriously looking at his corrupted lifestyle, you are proving his point that at least he was correct in saying believing women are deficient in intelligence.

aaron said...

@ lia Hu
have you ever thought that muhummed's example lead to deaths of many younger girls through his example with pre puberty marriages>?

rowland said...

@lia hu.

This is for you.

Narrated Usama bin Zaid: The
Prophet said, "After me I have
not left any affliction more
harmful to men than women."
Sahih Bukhari 7:62:33

Narrated 'Aisha: The things
which annual prayer were
mentioned before me (and
those were): a dog, a donkey
and a woman. I said, "You have
compared us (women) to donkeys
and dogs. By Allah! I saw the
Prophet praying while I used to lie
in (my) bed between him and the
Qibla. Whenever I was in need of
something, I disliked to sit and
trouble the Prophet. So, I would
slip away by the side of his feet."
Sahih Bukhari 1:9:493

Narrated Abu Said Al-Khudri:
Once Allah's Apostle went out to
the Musalla (to offer the prayer) o
'Id-al-Adha or Al-Fitr prayer. Then
he passed by the women and said,
"O women! Give alms, as I have
seen that the majority of the
dwellers of Hell-fire were you
(women)." They asked, "Why is it
so, O Allah's Apostle ?" He replied,
"You curse frequently and are
ungrateful to your husbands. I
have not seen anyone more
deficient in intelligence and
religion than you. A cautious
sensible man could be led astray
by some of you." The women
asked, "O Allah's Apostle! What is
deficient in our intelligence and
religion?" He said, "Is not the
evidence of two women equal
to the witness of one man?"
They replied in the affirmative. He
said, "This is the deficiency in
her intelligence. Isn't it true that
a woman can neither pray nor fast
during her menses?" The women
replied in the affirmative. He said,
"This is the deficiency in her
religion."
Sahih Bukhari 1:6:301

Why don't you go and LEARN about islam.

DrJohnCrow said...

I have done what you said and I have noticed a big difference between the Koran and the New Testament - I have never seen a GREEN bible

Deleting said...

Lia Hu said, "Muhammad (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him (PBUH)) is not a common person, so we should respect him accordingly. "

Just because someone says they're a prophet of God doesn't mean they are. Joseph Smith claimed prophethood. Jehovah Witnesses church (I think) claims prophethood as did Ellen G. White yet they gave different messages than each other and Mohammed who also gave different messages than the prophets of the bible.

"He brought us the last testimony of Allah (God) which is The Holy Quran. His (PBUH) life and the holy Quran together provide us the code of successful life. If we know the teachings of Jesus (PBUH), He (Jesus)confirms Muhammad's (PBUH) arrival and bound His (Jesus) followers to become faithful to Muhammad (PBUH), because Prophet Muhammad is the last Messenger of Allah (God)."

According to the Koran. According to the bible the only time Jesus could have been speaking of Muhammad was in the same context he was speaking of Joseph Smith, Ellen G White, etc.
Matthew 7:15 to 17.
“Beware of false prophets, who come to you in sheep’s clothing but inwardly are ravenous wolves. 16 You will recognize them by their fruits. Are grapes gathered from thornbushes, or figs from thistles? 17 So, every healthy tree bears good fruit, but the diseased tree bears bad fruit.

Or he could have been speaking about muhammad here too since muhammad claimed to be the long awaited prophecied one in the bible.

Matthew 24:23 to 26.
23 Then if anyone says to you, ‘Look, here is the Christ!’or ‘There he is!’do not believe it.

24 For false christs and false prophets will arise and perform great signs and wonders, so as to lead astray, if possible, even the elect.

25 See, I have told you beforehand.

26 So, if they say to you, ‘Look, he is in the wilderness,’do not go out. If they say, ‘Look, he is in the inner rooms,’do not believe it.

Cont

Deleting said...

Lia Hu said, "Mother Ayesha's wedding with the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH)at young age is the special blessing of Allah (God) on the human race. She was chosen to get lifelong guidance from the Prophet and train/reveal it to the Humanity (especialy our sisters, mothers and wife (or wives))."

Yet Ayesha also said believing women suffered more than disbelieving women so your whole point of islam leading to a successful life is bogus. A successful life doesn't include being beaten by your husband.

Boota Singh rowland already answered you on this post so I will save my word count to address the next bit.

"However, if you really want to be enlightened. I will encourage you to read a book on the life of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). Why? because then you will know who is Muhammad (PBUH)."

Lia you start with the presupposition that David hasn't read anything on islam. Why? He has been engaging muslims via tv and debates for at least 5 years maybe more and he's better read on muhammad and your religion than you are.
You know how I know that? Because your rhetorical is straight up from western imams who don't want you to read your sources.

"It is everybody's duty to get knowledge (most important! true knowledge)."

This is almost laughable because you're not doing any of it. Your simply playing parrot and repeating everything you hear and say without ever engaging the topic at hand or looking critically at it.
Knowledge means study and application and testing. It's good to question and it's good to think critically. You're not doing that.

Lia, if the koran said, "Lo! We inspire thee as We inspired Noah and the prophets after him, as We inspired Abraham and Ishmael and Isaac and Jacob and the tribes, and Jesus and Job and Jonah and Aaron and Solomon, and as We imparted unto David the Psalms;" (4:163 Pickthal)

And 33:40 "Muhammad was not the father of any man among you. He was a messenger of God and the final prophet. God is fully aware of all things"

Yet Jesus said in John 5:39 "You search the Scriptures because you think that in them you have eternal life; and it is they that bear witness about me,"

Well, this is the contradiction so which one is true?
Textual accuracy of text are determined in part by the number of manuscripts available and how old they are in relation to the events being described. Of course, chronological data and accurate representation also play a part as well.

The new testament stands up to this test. The Koran does not. You don't have the earliest fragments of the koran and your scholars have verified and given approval of the hadiths that say as such.
Then again, you don't need to. The pattern of speech and clear diction of God's words is consistent from the old testament to the new testament and Jesus's words.
And to think the bible is written over 1500 years with many old and new testament writers never meeting each other yet everything still flows together! Wild!

That pattern is broken in the koran. Allah (because this is his hadith) sounds nothing like the God of the bible!

Pray to God for wisdom with a sincere heart that you will use knowledge and not just spout off information you're given.

Radical Moderate said...

@David Wood

You might want to check this out and do a reply video.

Muslim responds with just error after error

An example of this is pointed out by another commenter Jake Blake. "Lebo puts a blurb in the video saying that the proof of his assertion for Joseph being 90 at the time of his marriage to Mary can be found in Dale Allison's commentary on Matthew. This is as factually incorrect. Allison says nothing of the sort on page 12."


Look at page 12

darkwingdave said...

Mr Ortolf, perhaps you should read up more on Sharia law and what it's based on. The Koran, the Sunna- which are composed of the Hadiths; the writings of Mohammed, Qiyas, or analogical deduction and Ijma, or scholarly consensus. These writings contain more details on how non-Muslims are to be treated than how Muslims are to live. It is also not just a religion but a social system dictating control of legal issues, dietary and hygiene issues and those pesky details like taqiyya that gives them permission to blatantly lie to non-Muslims.

albin zhabari said...

prohet muhammed and jezus are the same person people called muhammed with jezus when he really was allah messenger and he says that its sin for people who treat him(allah)good equally or join other good with him they are the sinful in islam because he is one that always existed and will exist he created devil to devil its cursed by allah because he doesnt want to decry to allah like others but allah give permission him to make trouble in people minds especially nonbelievers but for muslim thats not possible because he cant do that to them who believe and pray for allah very much people who doesnt believe after they read quran they cry why they cry because we doesnt know when we are alive or dead only he allah knows who guarante that someone can turn islam in end of life allah is merciful and forgiveness he created people with erros so that they can pray for forgiveness and have peace in life theres much to say but thats all peace and love brothers

albin zhabari said...

sorry theyre not the same jesus in islam name is isa he was prophet and the last prophet was muhammed sorry for mistake and i must apologize allah or god too for that mistake because he says in quran its very bad to change information but that was not with purpose

dana jam said...

You all should which the respond video for this videos it will explain all the misunderstanding that you guysh have about islam and the prophet Muhammad
I swear to god if you read about the islam and prophet Muhammad pbuh you will gone find out who he reallu is

dana jam said...

Which the respond video for this video and you will gone find out all the misconceptions that you have about Christianity islam and prophet Muhammad pbuh

David Wood said...

Dana,

I did watch the response video. It was thoroughly deceptive.

But let's focus on specifics. Give us an example of something Steven said that's false, and we'll look at what the Qur'an and Hadith say about it.