Thursday, July 10, 2008

David Wood vs. Sami Zaatari: "Was Muhammad a Prophet of God?"

Here's one of the debates I did back in March (part of the "Easter Debates"). I'm still waiting for an edited version (one that combines the footage from both cameras), but the raw footage will do for now. On an interesting note, I learned that I'm less aggressive when I debate in Virginia, where Muslim friends and their family members are sitting in the audience. I feel like I'm trying to break things to them gently (which isn't how I feel when I debate elsewhere). Anyhow, this was a fun debate. Sami Zaatari was a pleasure to work with, and I look forward to the two debates we're doing in September. I will certainly need to do a post on his "But Christianity suffers from all the same problems you're bringing up" tactic, since (a) I didn't really get to address this in the debate, and (b) I don't see how Christianity suffers from ANY of the problems I raised. One interesting aspect of this debate is that Sami didn't take the standard approach when dealing with certain criticisms such as the Satanic Verses or Muhammad's assassinations. Instead of denying that these events occurred, he simply argued that they're not really a problem for Islam. I was very impressed that he didn't throw out all of history (which seems to be the standard approach of Muslim debaters). Here's the debate for now. Sam Shamoun's commentary on the debate can be found here and here.

5 comments:

Yahya Hayder Seymour said...

At the end of the debate, Nadir Ahmed says that the Islamic Centre of Preoria offered an Apologist to debate you whom you ran away from, who was that?

David Wood said...

Me? I have no clue what he's talking about (I haven't watched the debate yet). I've never backed down from a debate. Indeed, ACP has asked Nadir to debate me, and he has utterly refused.

BlackBaron said...

Thanks for posting this debate.

David, I think you did a great job. Many of your points seemed to go over your opponent's head.

Some of Mohammed's revelations remind me of Joseph Smith's similar revelations especially concerning the right to take whomever was desired by the "prophet" as a wife.

Thanks again for your defense of the faith once for all delivered to the saints.

Bfoali said...

I have

Bfoali said...

I have to disagree with the last comment, david. I believe that Zaatari crushed all of your argumenets against the prophet muhammad (pbuh)I am actully shocked that the blackbaron thought you did a good job.
David wood, I think your a great person as well, who has true character in debates.
Peace