Tuesday, September 4, 2012

Egyptian Cleric Abd Al-Rahman Mansour Gives Guidelines for Wife-Beating in Islam

For more on Islamic prophet-approved violence towards women, click here.


Anonymous said...

This dude is a pimp.

Comedy at its finest.

gabriella oak said...

How come Muhammad missed out steps 1 and 2 and went straight to the hitting part ??

Perhaps he knew better than Allah how to deal with unruly wives.

Osama Abdallah said...


I've written detailed articles on this topic at: http://www.answering-christianity.com/beating.htm
, and proved that even in the Bible wife-beating to allowed. In fact, in the Bible is pretty much open. In Islam, at least, it is structured and limited.

As to the Prophet of Islam hitting Aisha with one minor hit, what bothers me from these types of "Scholars" is the following:

1- They worship the Prophet of Islam! Yes, this is far beyond just admiration or reverance. It's worship.

2- They don't and never and will never think for a second that an incident or a Saying (Hadith) or anything that the Prophet does or says
THAT GOES AGAINST THE QURAN is something that perhaps happened before the Revelation of the certain Quranic Law. In this video, the scholar failed to mention this. In fact, he should've only spoken about the Glorious Quran's Law and nothing more. I agree with Gabriella (surprising isn't it?) that yes, how come the Prophet of Islam failed to meet the Quranic Law? There are even Hadiths where the Prophet himself forbade hitting of wives. I mentioned them in the article. So this proves:

1- Either the Prophet lost his temper for a split second and did something that was beyond his human-control.

2- Either the story is a fabrication.

3- Or the Prophet did this before the Revelation of Noble Verse 4:34.

I just don't understand why our scholars are too obsessed with glorifying Prophet Muhammad to a worshipping level, where we have to document every little microscopic thing about him. I am always suspicious when I see LONG-BEARDED "scholars" explaining Islam. I know there is a big load of garbage about to get dumped somewhere down the line!

Now, I am definitely not a Hadiths rejecter. I don't reject the Hadiths. But at the same time, I don't feel it is necessary to use them all the time. If the Glorious Quran is sufficient enough to explain a situation, then that's it. The Quran after all, ACCORDING TO THE GLORIOUS QURAN ITSELF, is Muhaymin (has full and complete authority) above all texts. Muslims are quick to use this Noble Word that exists in multiple Noble Verses against the Bible's Scriptures when debating Christians. They tell them things such as:

"What agrees with the Quran we consider it closest to the Truth. Otherwise we reject it, because the Quran is MUHAYMIN over all texts."

Yet, when it comes to the Hadiths, THERE ARE SOME OF THESE LONG-BEARDED "scholars" who even dare to say that Hadith can abrogate the Quran! This is 100% absurd! And I dare say that it is blasphemy and a grave insult to Allah Almighty's Holy Words, especially when we have Hadiths such as the following:

"The Prophet used to invoke Allah, saying, "O Allah! Forgive my mistakes and my ignorance and my exceeding the limit (boundaries) of righteousness in my deeds; and forgive whatever You know better than I. O Allah! Forgive the wrong I have done jokingly or seriously, and forgive my accidental and intentional errors, all that is present in me." (Translation of Sahih Bukhari, Invocations, Volume 8, Book 75, Number 408)"

So after all, the Prophet's hit to Aisha COULD'VE BEEN A MERE JOKE that she as a woman took seriously!

These long-bearded clowns are just too amazing!

Osama Abdallah

Osama Abdallah said...

So now do I have to joke with my wife like this?! Am I supposed to copy every microscopic thing that the Prophet of Islam did?! Only to the idol worshipers of Muhammad I should. But I am not worshiper of any creation. I only worship Allah Almighty.

Like Abu Bakr, the first Islamic Caliph, said when the Prophet of Islam died:

"Whoever used to worship Muhammad, let him know that Muhammad is now dead! And whoever used to worship GOD, let him know that GOD is ALIVE AND NEVER DIES."

I am not a worshiper of Prophet Muhammad, or Jesus or anyone. I only worship Allah Almighty.

Osama Abdallah